The Great Outdoors Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people who love outdoor activities, excursions, and outdoorsmanship. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

One complaint about using the Munter hitch for belaying is that it twists and kinks the rope. After doing a full rope length rappel with a Munter hitch down a slightly overhanging face to the base of the climb, what is the best way for a pair of climber to get the twists and kinks out of the climbing rope (you can assume the rope is still hanging from the anchors and the climbers are standing on a wide open and secure area).

share|improve this question
1  
For the record, a figure eight will also twist the rope if you rappel/belay with it. – Roflo Mar 2 at 21:14
    
@Rolfo - This is true, it's best to leave the end of the rope just off the ground when using a figure 8 so the rope is free to twist and untwist. – ShemSeger Mar 2 at 21:48
    
Curious. My testing shows that a figure eight does not twist rope. I always carry one as a backup device in case something happens to the ATC. – Joshua Mar 2 at 21:58
    
@Joshua Strange, I stopped using a figure eight as my main rappel device (more than a decade ago) because I hated having my rope twisted. I haven't tested it since, so I can't offer more that this anecdotal bit. – Roflo Mar 2 at 22:02
up vote 7 down vote accepted

Good grief. The question was about getting the kinks out, not the merits of the Munter (which is invaluable, see David Fasulo's Self Rescue).

The best option, while on the rock, esp. if it is a nice day, is to hang your rope from one end, and slightly weight the other (to keep it from blowing around, tangling in trees, whatever). If you have a swivel (e.g. like you would use on a haul bag), you can use that to connect the rope to any anchor and tension the rope (this can be in a parking lot, just be sure that the car you tie it to is your own). Both of these will gently uncoil the rope.

Another option is to do an old-fashioned mountaineers coil and just make sure you are twisting the rope in the correct direction.

share|improve this answer
    
The first sentence doesn't really add to this answer, I'd remove it – Liam Mar 8 at 8:40

The one way I know to remove the twists from a climbing rope, requires for the rope not to be hanging nor in use in any way.

The procedure is quite simple but may require help from your partner:

  1. Have your parter attach an ATC with a carabiner to the belay loop in her harness (if your partner is otherwise engaged, you can tie the ATC and carabiner to a rock or tree with some webbing).
  2. Push one end of the rope through the ATC in the way you'd use it to belay (through the top of the ATC, around the carabiner, and back out through the ATC).
  3. Pull the full rope length through the system.

And that's it. For really twisted ropes you might have to do it more than once.

share|improve this answer
2  
This is good advice, just don't expect a badly twisted rope to get perfectly "straight" again - it will not happen. Even if it appears so, the wrinkles will come up again quickly. – imsodin Mar 2 at 19:06
    
If you have an ATC, then why are you descending on a munter? – ShemSeger Mar 2 at 21:06
1  
@ShemSeger You might have left your ATC at home and you do this procedure when you get home. Or maybe 2 people descended but only one has an ATC. Oh, and a figure eight will also twist the rope if you rappel with it. – Roflo Mar 2 at 21:09
    
@Rolfo As long as you had at least pne extra carabiner, then you could make a minimalist carabiner brake, and rappel on that instead of ruining your rope with a munter hitch. – ShemSeger Mar 2 at 21:37
1  
Supporting documentation for this may be found in pages 52-54 of "The Outdoor Knots Book" at books.google.com/… – requiem Mar 2 at 23:39

The main trick for getting the kinks out of a rope after using a Munter is not getting them in in the first place.

The Munter hitch differs from almost all other belay systems in the respect that the rope going in and the rope going out are to be kept side-by-side. With basically all other belay devices, the rope leaves the belay hand towards the belay device at the thumb. With the Munter hitch, both rope going in and out being side-by-side, it's the pinky side instead.

The blocking position for a Munter is with the belay rope pointing up. It still has enough friction when the belay rope points down (which is why some consider it "good enough" to use a Munter like any other belay device), but it moves uncontrollably about when switching rope direction and may position itself such that the rope unscrews the biner.

Old hands who position and use the Munter correctly are not particularly well-received in climbing gyms since stupid newcomers tend to mimic their rope-handling, and while a Munter handled like any other device becomes quirky and rope-kinking but at least retains enough friction (unless it unscrews itself in the process), most other belay devices handled in the manner of a Munter do not provide sufficient friction for catching a fall.

There are various special belay biners that try fixing and securing a biner where a wrong-sided Munter hitch will not move it about.

But this is where we are getting back to the kinked ropes: if you feed the rope in and out at the same side, the Munter bends the rope similarly in each direction. Consequently, it will not kink. Also more of the friction will be rope-around-biner friction rather than rope-to-rope friction, so the rope will also fray/fuzz less.

Now for rappelling, feeding from the top is actually rather awkward. So particularly the hardcore alpine Munter lovers will carry an eight for rappelling.

If you rappelled using a Munter, particularly as a bottomfeeder (make very very sure that it does not run over the screw), the rope will look exceptionally bad: this is not a regular technique but emergency only. Have someone with a good rappelling device and a good mood rappel right behind you (and he can forget about using an autobloc or similar friction knot). That will help the rope. Passing it from one side to the other will also help, but that's not really doable when you still need to pull it. At least try disentangling the end going up.

These days, new ropes have a core-mantle-displacement of 0 anyway. Old ropes may not have been fixed similarly: those kink the worst. If your rope is older than 15 years, you should have changed it long ago anyway. Even if much of that has been shelf life.

share|improve this answer
3  
Maybe I shouldn't have used a Munter as an example. There are lots of things that put twists and links into ropes. – StrongBad Mar 2 at 22:43

The Halbmastwurfsicherung (half clove hitch) or "Munter Hitch" was one of those accidental discoveries. Someone back in the day tied a clove hitch wrong and discovered that the resulting knot had some potential application in belaying and descending.

Munters are however, the WORST discovery ever made for your ropes, and should only be used in emergency situations, or as a backup.

I only use munter hitches as a backup belay when I'm teaching kids how to rappel, and I never let the knot get tight unless I need to stop a fall. Never use a munter hitch for rappelling if you have some other descending device to use instead. The only time I let people rappel on munters is from a rappel tower, when I'm teaching them knots and letting them gain some experience, I've never used one outside a controlled environment, and never plan to.

The best way to get the twist out of your rope after rappelling on a munter, is to let the rope hang free. I never let my rope touch the ground when rappelling off my platform, that way the rope can twist in open air while you descend, and doesn't get all knotted up at the bottom, then when you get to the ground and untie from the rope, it mostly twists back. I try to alternate my descents on the rope by tying the munter both left and right handed, so it isn't twisting the rope the same way every time.

If you have two people descending on a rope, you could have one go down on a right-handed munter, and the second on a left-handed munter, this may leave you with less of a knot at the bottom.


Tip: If you're using a munter hitch as a result of failing to pack necessary gear, or dropping your device, then you can make an old school carabiner braking device, which is what they used to do before dedicated descending devices were developed. You can build a minimalist carabiner braking device with only two carabiners.

enter image description here Image Source: Freedom of the Hills.

share|improve this answer
1  
Each to their own. While presumably because I fall too much, I have never had the sheath of a rope wear out before the core. I predominantly use a Munter when trad climbing. – StrongBad Mar 2 at 22:11

Avoid the problem with a better solution

Avoiding the twisting in the first place surely is best, and there is a simple way to do that:

enter image description here

This is the Super Munter, Monster Munter, or Double Munter. It is essentially a second Munter tied over the first in the opposite direction, and this symmetry means that it does not twist the rope. It provides tremendous braking power but it also works with lighter weight as well. References:


Attempting to answer the question as asked

Due to the separate parts of a standard kernmantle rope twists can happen differentially between the core and sheath (kern and mantle) which can make completely straitening a badly kinked rope quite difficult compared to single-braid ropes. From my experience with shorter pieces of kernmantle cord I think tensioning the entire length of rope at once and untwisting that is a helpful complement to the pull-through method Roflo described. Since you described an overhanging rappel I would therefore bundle up all the rope that is on the ground and tie it to the hanging rope so that it is off the ground, and add any practical weight that is small enough to turn freely. The greatest twisting should be in the part that is not in the bundle as that part did not pass through the Munter. When you pull the rope what twisting remains will hopefully come out well enough.

I have never done a full-length rappel on a (single) Munter so this is speculation.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.