Take the 2-minute tour ×
The Great Outdoors Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people who love outdoor activities, excursions, and outdoorsmanship. It's 100% free, no registration required.

What are the criteria used for grading a trek? One article that I came across provided the following set criteria for grading:

  • Duration.
  • Terrain (includes altitude).
  • Exit routes.
  • Weather/Climate.

Is there is an official way of grading, or an agreed set of attributes within the trekking community regarding the same?

EDIT: I have removed the reference to Annapurna trek aiming to keep the discussion generic to trekking and not specific to treks from the himalayan range.

Second Edit: Removed the part where I referred to a trek being classified as easy/difficult. Now the question is more focused on the criteria of grading a trek and nothing more.

share|improve this question

2 Answers 2

up vote 6 down vote accepted

In my experience, you need to calibrate each guidebook or website to your own experience.

As a case study, I can speak from experience with two guidebooks describing hikes and treks in the same region:

  • På Fjälltur: Abisko Kebnekaise, describes lots of trails in the area around Nikkaluokta and Abisko. They grade trails at a scale of 1–10. I've found routes graded as "7/10 difficult" to be quite easy, routes graded as "4/10 normal" to be very easy, and no route is graded below 3/10. Trails described as steep, I found no problem at all.
  • På tur i Narvik og omegn, parts I and II, describe many trails and hike in the area around Narvik, just across the Swedish-Norwegian border from Abisko. Hikes are graded on a scale from 1 to 4. I've seen hikes described as "child-friendly" that I considered quite scary myself, with lots of boulders, steep slopes where losing balance is fatal, and wild rivers. I've made the mistake of trying a descent described as "steep", it was the most vertiginous descent I've ever done and would not recommend it to anyone loving their life.

I have some experience with these two guidebooks, so I know what I can do. There's no trail mentioned in the Swedish guidebook (På Fjälltur) that I would avoid on a backpacking trip, but for many of the trails from the Norwegian book, I would. Subjectively, on a 1-to-1 mapping, I would map any trails from the Swedish book rated 1–7 to be rated 1 in the Norwegian book, Swedish trails 8–10 rated 2 or 3 in the Norwegian book, with the Swedish book not containing anything rated 4 in the Norwegian one. Some routes are even described in both books.

This is just an example, but for me, it clearly illustrates that there is no universal set of guidelines. It depends very much on the standard and who one keeps in mind. It seems Norwegian kids are born on a a slope and they go mountain hiking in kindergarten on trails where 20-year old men from other countries would be scared. A Dutch hiking book may consider a route "difficult" because it's 20 km (even if all is paved and of course flat). So, no. There is no official grading or agreed upon set of attributes.

share|improve this answer
Brilliant. If I were to summarize what you answered, a trekking route is not just subjective to the people involved but also to the region involved. And hence, the criteria or attributes can vary based on the region as well as "who grades a trek". –  Unsung Oct 22 '13 at 16:56

Well established treks like the Annapurna circuit are rated by multiple trekking agencies. I would use those agencies rating as a reference point to differentiate between multiple well-established treks.

For example you can compare the difficulty of different treks in Nepal according to Himalayan Glacier.

share|improve this answer
Okay, I'll edit the question and remove the "Annapurna" part. My question was aimed at being more generic. Purely about any kind of trek in any region of the world. Also, the "attributes" for a trek are the things I'm more interested in. Using a reference might not workout when comparing a 2 day trek with a 10 days one. –  Unsung Sep 20 '13 at 6:11

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.