Take the 2-minute tour ×
The Great Outdoors Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people who love outdoor activities, excursions, and outdoorsmanship. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Tent vs bivvy bag - different camping experience, protection from the elements, comfort and weight? What are the pros and cons of both? Is it even a valid comparison - e.g. is it viable to rely on multi-day camping if you only have a bivvy bag or on the contrary does it make it easier to find somewhere to sleep?

share|improve this question
add comment

3 Answers 3

up vote 7 down vote accepted

Tents, tarps, and bivvy sacks are three different specialized tools for three different jobs.

Tarp

I typically prefer a tarp to either a tent or a bivvy sack, but that's because I do most of my camping in California in the summer, when the weather tends to be quite dry. In summer in the Sierra, I usually bring a tarp but sleep in the open and never take the tarp out of my pack. A tarp is easiest to set up if you have trees, and works best if there is no wind. Setting up a tarp takes some skill and practice. In a wind, it's hard to keep a tarp from flapping noisily and keeping you awake. The great thing about tarps is that they can be so compact and light. My tarp is 6.5 oz (180 g).

Tent

If I know that a trip is going to involve snow camping, I'd prefer a tent. Some people prefer tents to tarps for summer camping because they keep bugs out, but what works well for me in mosquito season is to sleep in a headnet until the air gets cold enough that the bugs become inactive. Expensive ultralight summer tents can be almost as light and compact as a tarp.

Bivvy sack

If I'm planning to do a climb in snow in a single day, but want a safety net in case I need to camp, I might bring a bivvy sack as a more compact and lightweight alternative to bringing a tent that I don't expect to use. I have one and have brought it as an emergency tool, but have never slept in it. I have talked to quite a few people who have used bivvy sacks, and none of them ever had anything good to say about spending a night in one. Everybody complains about condensation building up inside the sack, leaving you sleeping in a pool of water. Bivvy sacks vary a lot in weight. Mine is 8.5 oz (240 g), but I've seen others that are as much as 39 oz (1100 g), which seems absurd to me since you could get a tent that weighs the same amount.

share|improve this answer
    
anyone got anything to add on the tarp side of things for anywhere that isn't bone dry. –  Andrew Welch Mar 24 at 17:55
    
@AndrewWelch: Tarps work in the rain. They're meant to keep the rain off, and they do that. –  Ben Crowell Mar 24 at 21:03
    
I think a good variation or combination is a shaped/closed tarp with a very light bivy with a watertight bottom, but splashproof/breathable top on a small groundsheet. This is similar to a two-layer tent where the inner tent is shrunk. (You can even get the closable tarps with a short net skirt at the edges for bug resistance.) This worked for me for a wet overnight trip in Scotland and I will happily try that for two nights next. The whole setup weighs around 1kg including a walking pole. –  nsandersen Mar 25 at 23:24
add comment

Bivvy

Pros:

  • Very light. Minimum weight.
  • Ease of finding a place to sleep. Stealth bivvying is easier.
  • Very quick to setup or pack away, even in the dark. Helpful if you need to make a quick departure.
  • You are at one with nature. Very little between you and the wild. You can fall to sleep looking at the stars.

Cons:

  • Condensation. Sleeping bag will get damp. (You can mitigate against this by using a more expensive breathable bivvy bag and a synthetic sleeping bag or using a hydrophobic down sleeping bag (you can do the treatment yourself))
  • Midges. You can avoid these usually by bivvying on the top of the mountain.
  • If the weather gets bad and you close yourself in it is more claustrophobic.

  • For multiday trips you'll need to dry stuff out in a bothy/hostel every 2/3 days.

  • You have no option to bring your backpack and footwear inside, exposing them to the elements and animals (though a cheap plastic garbage bag is a great solution for this).

Tent:

Pros:

  • More comfortable. More space.
  • Protected from the weather.
  • A lightweight tent, I use an Akto, can be only slightly heavier than a bivvy bag.
  • Much less condensation.
  • Can do long multi-day trips.

Cons:

  • Heavier.
  • More expensive. For a lightweight one.
  • Harder to find a camping spot. Harder to stealth camp.
  • You are separated from nature.

For more about bivvying a must read is "The Book of the Bivvy" by Ronald Turnbull. For more about being close to nature read "The Wild Places" by Robert Macfarlane.

share|improve this answer
add comment

I have run into this HYPOTHETICAL dilemma with bivvy sacs: I have long liked the idea of a little cocoon to just snap to a couple points and presto sleep.

Each time I camp, I look around either while pitching my tent, or in the A.M. when the sun comes up if I have to, just to take in the location, and maybe consider a few what-ifs.

I have often seen places where there is not a lot of practicality for bivvy sacs due to the lack of natural fixtures to append them to. What I mean is; it sure sounds cool in theory to string your hammock or bivvy sac to a set of trees, but in practice that is not always possible.

Consider your terrain, know it well, know your overnight spots and ask people on forums who may have been there if you can.

I am considering a Pacific Crest Trail run to Oregon this summer and I really want to take a bivvy sac, but I don't think I can reliably guarantee a set of trees to sling it on at all times. Sometimes you just gotta crash out, and the darkness has set in, you become dangerously tired.. that trail is too narrow and a mess to just improvise outside a designated overnight spot..

I have seen this in a few spots along the PCT in the North Cascades, and what I came away thinking is it would be real inconvenient if I had brought a bivvy sac.

That being said, I obviously am not a seasoned bivvy sac user; so take my observations lightly with a grain of salt. However; that is my take on the bivvy sac dilemma.

share|improve this answer
    
As you seem to closely relate hammocks and bivvy sacks and talk a lot about finding spots to hang things, could it be that you confuse bivouac sack ("bivvy") with a portaledge? –  Benedikt Bauer Mar 24 at 18:23
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.