Take the 2-minute tour ×
The Great Outdoors Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people who love outdoor activities, excursions, and outdoorsmanship. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I'm going on a one day hike, and I want to cook an egg whilst on it. I'd like to avoid carrying excess water, and the route goes past a couple of waterfalls and several streams, so there is no problem in acquiring extra water. However, I don't know whether there would be risks from bacteria in the water getting into the egg, meaning I would have to purify the water first.

share|improve this question
2  
Chicken eggs shells are porous - this site which is to do with general egg production has some interesting information about washing eggs / bacteria poultryclub.org - I've never personally cooked an egg in dirty water, but do keep chickens and we always wash our eggs after they have been laid but that's it. –  Aravona Sep 3 at 10:07
1  
Can you clarify do you mean dirty water or simply water that hasn't come out of a tap? –  Liam Sep 3 at 10:21
1  
@Liam Either - I imagine that the water will be physically clean, but I'm not sure. –  sweeneyrod Sep 3 at 10:33
6  
@Aravona Interesting side-fact: In the USA, law requires that eggs are washed before they can be sold. They thus always require refrigeration. In the EU however, you are not allowed to wash them. This keeps the natural protective film intact which simply dries. Unwashed eggs don't need to be refrigerated for a couple of weeks. If you get eggs in the US, I'd thus hard-boil all the eggs before starting the trip. That way, they are also safe for a couple of days probably. –  Holger Just Sep 3 at 16:05
2  
According to this boiling for 1 minute should be enough to deal with Giardia, boiling an egg will take longer. +1 on boiling the eggs before you leave, it's easier anyway :) –  AVee Sep 3 at 16:10

3 Answers 3

up vote 21 down vote accepted

First things first. You do not need to purify all water sources. Just because it is not out of a tap does not make it immediately dirty. Most fresh wilderness water (providing it isn't stagnant, etc.) is fine for drinking.

You should be familiar with the source of the water. Just because the river looks clean doesn't mean that an industrial unit isn't dumping into it upstream. I always check a river on a map before using it. Generally a mountain stream above human habitation will be fine.

Providing the water is fine for drinking there is no reason not to boil an egg in the same water, if anything it's going to be safer.


If the water is actually dirty (e.g. polluted, stagnant, in a built up area, etc.) Then no, don't boil your egg in it.

Most bacteria should be destroyed by the boiling, but things like heavy metals, etc. will survive boiling and this can either enter the egg (though the shell) or be passed onto the inner egg from the shell when you break it (cross contamination)

share|improve this answer
2  
Liam -- regarding the first part, based on what I've read in the past, shouldn't one be wary of all wilderness water (even fast-moving) because of the potential for things like tapeworm eggs from animal droppings? –  Doc Sep 3 at 18:04
1  
Most "fresh wilderness water" is far more "fine for drinking" than the processed concotion for which you pay $x per bottle at home. Nature is better at this than we are. –  Lightness Races in Orbit Sep 4 at 0:27
3  
@Doc: based on what I've read in the past, shouldn't one be wary of all wilderness water (even fast-moving) because of the potential for things like tapeworm eggs from animal droppings? Where have you read this, and what wilderness areas do you have in mind? There is copious evidence that, e.g., water in the Sierra does not need to be treated. Are you thinking of giardia or other protozoan cysts, and perhaps misremembering this as tapeworms? In any case, there is no known disease-causing organism present in backcountry water that would survive boiling. –  Ben Crowell Sep 4 at 3:12
2  
@LightnessRacesinOrbit: That's not really true, and nature isn't all that great at it anyway. –  whatsisname Sep 4 at 3:42
2  
@LightnessRacesinOrbit: Nature doesn't have a job. It just is what it is. The natural world is rough, disease filled, and violent. For most critters, life is a brutal experience barely clinging to survival. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_nature . And we don't do things through magic, they are done with science and technology. –  whatsisname Sep 4 at 13:09

As someone with +10 years experience as a boyscout, i never had an incident or heard of an incident where cooking with wilderness water led to bacteria infections, sickness, etc.

You should take care not to use stagnant water (this was also mentioned in other answers) and I'd personally avoid very shallow streams, to avoid dirt and bacteria from the ground polluting the water.

If you want to be as safe as possible, make sure the water has been boiling for some time before putting the eggs in it.


On a sidenote:

Since it is supposed to be a one-day hike and you don't mention anything else, I assume that the trip will be somewhere near to you. If you are visiting a foreign country, I'd definitely make sure beforehand that the water sources there are safe to drink from (i. e. I probably wouldn't do this without proper water filtration in some African or South-American (or even European) countries).

share|improve this answer
1  
I don't get it. Are you concerned that nature is unclean outside of the USA? –  Lightness Races in Orbit Sep 4 at 0:26
1  
@LightnessRacesinOrbit: Ecosystem damage is pretty rampant outside the 'first world'. –  whatsisname Sep 4 at 3:43
    
@LightnessRacesinOrbit I honestly couldn't tell what nature in the USA is like in terms of "cleanliness" since I've never been there. As whatsisname correctly remarked, one point of concern would be ecosystem damage, the other one being bacteria/pathogens/pests in the water which might be resistant to heat or be introduced into my system by some other means. Especially since they might not occur in "developed" (I don't particularly like that term) countries, making it more likely (for me as a foreigner) to actually conduct a disease from them. –  barghest Sep 4 at 10:31
2  
@barghest, you do realise that the EU has considerably higher standards/legislation on environmental pollution than the US? –  Liam Sep 4 at 10:57
1  
@Liam I am aware of that, of course. What I meant is that I couldn't say out of personal experience whether water sources there are more polluted or not. –  barghest Sep 4 at 11:27

Yes you can but the question you need to ask yourself is should you ? If the water is dirty it will contaminate the egg (some toxins are horribly bad for you)

Most fresh (flowing) spring water is VERY clean if above human habitation areas

share|improve this answer
2  
this doesn't appear to answer the question very well. Only point 3 is relevant and that could of easily been put into a comment and has by Pereris –  Liam Sep 3 at 12:56
    
OK Liam Thanks - am very new here and obviously need to improve protocol to adhere to relevance - thanks –  James Ferguson Sep 3 at 12:59
    
Liam - 1) Qualifies the question - The accurate answer would be YES - it is unqualified that you CAN boil an egg in dirty water. –  James Ferguson Sep 3 at 13:01
    
Liam 2) Qualifies the relevance This question does not invite a yes / no answer despite the wording –  James Ferguson Sep 3 at 13:02
    
I've tried to reword it to be easier to read. If you disagree with my edit you can undo it. I think the bullet points where confusing the meaning? –  Liam Sep 3 at 13:29

protected by Liam Sep 4 at 14:24

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality answers, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site.

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.