I've often read and been told that with foraging less is often more. Whilst you may need X kilograms of a berry or flowers (like elderflowers) you should never pick a bush clean.

How can you estimate when to move on to the next bush, or not pick at all, would it be like leave at least half?

What's the reason to leave an amount on the bush?

2 Answers 2


(TL:DR -- The "safe" amount to harvest varies enormously with plant species and context. When in doubt, take 5% or less. 1/3 is probably safe for common, prolific species.)

This rule is given out because if you harvest every fruit on a plant, you've stopped it from reproducing this year. You don't necessarily even have to harvest all the fruit, if the plant has a generally low seed-germination rate. It gets a little more complicated if you're harvesting things other than fruit, too: taking a wild carrot kills it outright, meaning that unless its seeds have already ripened and been dispersed, that's 100% of its reproductive capacity gone. Same, and even worse, for annual species harvested that way.

In scientific collections, the general rule I was taught is to leave at least 95% of a population -- that is, to kill no more than 1 in 20 plants, or to strip no more than 5% of the population's reproductive capacity. This is a good solid rule, especially when you're dealing with relatively uncommon wild species or species that are slow to recover from harvest. Frankly, though, foragers shouldn't take any of those unless it's literally a matter of starvation.

Elderberry* is neither rare nor slow to recover; it flowers and fruits prolifically, year after year. You could likely harvest a third of its fruit, or even more, without damaging the population's long-term reproductive capacity. Be careful to leave enough for the animals that depend on the fruits, though! Personally, I definitely won't take more than 1/3 of a native species population.

All that said, there are some edible plants whose extirpation would be a public service. Look up your local noxious weeds, and harvest those to your heart's content. Take more than you need! Take all you can carry! Kill them off, please!

Did you have any specific plants in mind, other than elderberry? I could do some research and get you firmer numbers for them.

* Assuming you mean one of the more common Sambucus species -- S. nigra or S. racemosa or something -- in North America or Europe. I'm not well-up on the whole genus.

  • Amazing answer! Thank you. Not really as I was after a general rule of thumb idea. This answer is ideal for that.
    – Aravona
    Commented Dec 9, 2015 at 21:17

I think this is a question of sustainability. If you strip a bush of its flowers and/or fruit, then it loses the opportunity to reproduce this year, or ever in the case of annuals and/or patches of wild veg in which you harvest the whole plant.

Basically you want to leave some behind to continue the species where you found it.

In desert cultures this is even taken one step further. If you see a lone flower in the desert, carefully dig it up and relocate it to a place with others of its kind, this allows that lone flower a greater chance to reproduce.

  • Thanks for the info, the part about desert cultures is really interesting. Any ideas about the other half of this question?
    – Aravona
    Commented Dec 9, 2015 at 19:01
  • 5
    Re the last paragraph of your answer, can you add a reference, or attest to your own expertise in transplanting desert plants? Some plants, even in a well-tended garden, are easy to transplant, others very difficult. I'd be very nervous about digging up a desert plant, replanting it, and walking away.
    – ab2
    Commented Dec 9, 2015 at 19:13
  • I don't think I can answer that. Different plants have different levels of procreation. I.e. One may be very prolific where others may only have one or two pups a year. And as far as the desert thing is concerned I should probably limit that to south western North America, and my source is studying shamanism over 30 years ago. I highly doubt being able to find those sources and citing them as references. Sorry.
    – Escoce
    Commented Dec 9, 2015 at 20:01

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.