14

In 3D archery and while hunting we're aiming for the lungs and the heart most of the time. At least this is true for bobcats, lynxes, deer and other similar animals.

See this target for example:

Deer practice

According to films and stuff, the best way to kill a human is to shoot in the head.

Is this true? An if yes, why doesn't this also apply to animals?

  • 2
    The most effective way to kill a human is a shot to the chest. A chest is a much bigger target and much worse protected by bone. Same for hunting. – user2766 Dec 15 '15 at 17:37
  • 4
    Another possible reason not mentioned is that some hunters are looking to keep the skull / antlers intact for trophy purposes, which would likely be damaged by a head shot. – Michael McGriff Dec 15 '15 at 18:07
  • FWIW, some animals you do shoot in the head, e.g. wild turkeys. – whatsisname Mar 17 '18 at 16:35
  • I think you accepted the wrong answer. The only answer that includes Archery is this one by Dronz – James Jenkins Mar 19 '18 at 16:58
20

Compare a human skull to that of a deer. The human skull is dominated by the brain, so a shot to the head is likely to penetrate the cranium and brain.

On the other hand, a deer brain is very small compared to the skull and presents a very small target. Furthermore there are bony stuctures which might deflect away a bullet or arrow. See this picture of a fallow deer skull.

enter image description here

Generally, large muscles need large anchor points, so an animal with strong neck muscles or strong jaw muscles will often have bony lumps and flanges on its skull (e.g. the sagital crest on a gorilla skull).

A sagittal crest is a ridge of bone running lengthwise along the midline of the top of the skull (at the sagittal suture) of many mammalian and reptilian skulls, among others.

In contrast, a deflected shot off a rib is still likely to go on and penetrate heart or lungs. And a big animal like a deer is going to need a big heart and big lungs to oxygenate such a large body.

  • 1
    I believe we shoot the chest around the heart/lungs because when the animal moves, the head swings back and forth making it a harder target. Any noise can catch the animal's attention and the head would move from lower the ground grassing to a meter and a half (for a little deer) above the ground in a split of second. – Desorder Feb 22 '16 at 22:07
  • Nice article: outdoorlife.com/blogs/big-buck-zone/2012/09/… – OddDeer Jun 4 '16 at 6:32
18

The head tends to be a harder target to hit than the vital organs in the center of the body, but a penetrating hit there is more likely to take a human or animal to unconsciousness and inability immediately.

That's more important to do to a human who may have a weapon that can hit you back quickly, than it is to a nearly-defenseless animal you are hunting from a distance. However, in general police and military also train to target the "center of mass" of humans, too, as the most likely way in general to incapacitate a target, given that in fighting situations (as opposed to shooting an unmoving animal), misses are very common.

Some large animals and even humans also have skulls that may deflect or effectively stop or reduce the impact of an arrow (or bullet). Combined with the harder target and the chance the animal may suddenly move its head out of the line of fine being greater than them moving their entire body suddenly, the odds of getting a hit that results in an eventual dead animal are greater if you aim for the body.

  • 1
    This is the only answer that seems to notice this is a question about archery – James Jenkins Mar 19 '18 at 16:56
7

It does apply, in some cases - it's actually a preference.

For small game such as rabbits a neat little shot to the head with a high powered air rifle will kill the rabbit and save you from having to get the shot out afterwards. This is also most likely with small game that it's going to be much harder to pick out heart or lungs to aim to, the head is a clearer shot.

For larger game there is the choice, deer, as in your example, stand high in the grass and it's much easier to pick out where the heart or lung shots would be.

The reason people often pick heart or lung shots, especially with deer, is that a single shot kill is much more humane, and responsible, than having to shoot twice. The pro to shooting for the brain is the death should be instantaneous, the con is the target size... if you miss you'll spook the deer and it'll flee.

The choice of shot will also depend on distance, bullet, your shooting ability, weather conditions...

As for humans, well, a good shot anywhere can cause us to bleed out and die. It's almost the same preference - a head or chest shot can kill a person, but you're more likely to survive the latter.

This article is quite interesting: outdoor life - where to shoot a deer for one shot kills

6

A headshot is a high percentage HIT if done perfectly, but it is not a high percentage SHOT to do perfectly.

The brain (which is the actual intended target) is a small target, a miss of the exact target leads to a very ineffective alternate hit, it moves more, and it is more armored (which on glancing shots can increase the chance of ricochet, this is especially true for archery).

By contrast the "boiler room" heart/lung shot is larger, in significantly less motion at any given moment, and an imperfect shot still has a fairly large buffer of "still decent" hits around it.

For a skilled enough shooter with a fairly close range and a very fortuitous few moments of extremely limited head movement may come across a situation where some of those factors are negated enough where a head shot becomes viable...with a rifle. Even that is a fairly rare set of circumstances, but for archery this is practically never true. Even on the much less moving boiler room area the deer still often jumps/moves between the release of the shot and the impact of the arrow, the standard of accuracy is not as high (it's not common to put 1" groups at 100 yards with arrows...it is with rifles), and the armor of the skull is a significantly bigger problem for arrows (they'll go through on a straight hit, sure, but they are much more susceptible to glancing if they hit angled to the area they impact, which is easy to have happen on such a non-flat surface as a deer skull).

For deer it is basically rarely a viable shot with a rifle, and never a viable shot with an arrow.

6

This question arises basically for one reason. Movies are wrong. Any cop or soldier (even snipers) are trained to shoot center of mass. This is because it's far easier to hit, and still highly lethal. The head is a relatively fast moving, and smaller target. The skull also provides much more armour than the ribcage.

As well demonstrated by @mikeagg the brain is a very small target on a deer, and all the reasons that apply to humans apply even moreso to deer.

  • 2
    That's not true. Marines are taught chest and head shots. Without scoring proper headshots in the t-box of the target it would actually be very hard to pass table 2 (part of yearly qualification). Snipers most definitely have a large amount of training in headshots, many CQB type special forces actually default to headshots and spend most of their training focusing on them, and in Fallujah there were so many headshots that Marines were investigated for suspected executions (turns out they weren't executions, Marines just focused on headshots cuz they were dealing with a lot of drugged people). – Jimbo Jonny Dec 18 '15 at 18:57
  • The again, the deer brain is a lot smaller than a human one, and the Marines don't use bows and arrows. They also aren't expected to get humane kills while avoiding suffering like hunters are. Headshots with bow and arrow = bad plan. – Jimbo Jonny Dec 18 '15 at 18:59

protected by Charlie Brumbaugh Apr 28 at 0:37

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.