17

I'm a beginner climber. There are many climbers all over my area (doing cliffs). Would it be polite, impolite, or neutral, to approach groups and ask them if I could join them? Maybe this is 'obviously' impolite, but I've had a group offer before, so I wonder if this is just part of climbing etiquette. FYI - the climbers are from all different countries (lots of Germans, Australians, and others.)

  • 1
    I kind of feel this is opinion based? – user2766 Apr 5 '16 at 13:57
  • 2
    @Liam, maybe? In my experience "climbers are a friendly lot" but couldn't offer more than that as a possible answer. I know I have asked other groups to belay me but after observing them to make sure they know what they're doing. – Roflo Apr 5 '16 at 14:10
  • 1
    Indoors, I would definitely consider it normal and OK to ask, but you do have to be more careful about trusting yourself to an incompetent belayer. Outdoors, I think it's complicated and depends on the situation. A pretty common situation outdoors is that group A and group B have set up topropes next to each other, and they take turns climbing on each other's ropes. Often if you just hang out and watch someone climbing a route, you don't have to ask -- they will offer to belay you. – Ben Crowell Apr 5 '16 at 21:01
  • 1
    @BenCrowell - So just sit there with my harness and shoes watching? Would that seem pushy? – horse hair Apr 5 '16 at 21:13
  • 4
    A climber was killed in Australia after he was invited to join strangers on a climb. The top rope was set up by someone with no training and was thread though a sling. It failed as he was lowered off. Make sure when you climb with strangers you know what you are getting into. – user5330 Apr 6 '16 at 4:44
27

My answer is "don't ask". It's not so much that it's "impolite", but it's an imposition to them and potentially dangerous for you:

  • Belaying can take quite some time, so you're asking the person to give up a chunk of their recreation time to a total stranger. It's not like you're asking someone to help for 30 seconds
  • You're putting your life in their hands, literally. That's a big decision. What if they're also a complete novice but feel embarrassed to admit it. I wouldn't let anyone belay me unless I was confident they knew what they were doing and trusted them to do it
  • Don't go to a two-person sport venue by yourself. What if you get to the cliff and no one else is there?

Find a climbing partner(s). Learn together. It can be rewarding and build a great relationship as you both improve. You'll have someone to share your climbing highs and lows with.

  • Thanks for the good answer. Doesn't finding a partner and learning together necessitate trusting myself to a complete novice also, though? – horse hair Apr 5 '16 at 18:44
  • 6
    @horsehair of course. You should probably get lessons from an expert before going out into the wild. Maybe do a climbing course either together, or just yourself and teach your partner what you learned. Or join a climbing club and pair up with an experienced climber to learn. It's really important you get the techniques right. It's easy to die while climbing - many do. Having a partner also means you can go to any venue any time and climb. – Bohemian Apr 5 '16 at 18:49
  • 1
    This answer very closely mirrors my feelings. I also wouldn't do it, mostly for the second bullet point, you're literally putting your life in the hands of someone you don't know. I also doubt I would allow someone to join my group (consider I haven't done any climbing for decades now), you're adding a potential threat to your group and there's almost no upside to doing so. I've never climbed at a gym, so I don't know the etiquette there, but it may be more acceptable to ask there. – delliottg Apr 5 '16 at 21:53
  • 1
    @delli at a gym, there's usually spare staff floating around for this very purpose. – Bohemian Apr 6 '16 at 4:34
  • 2
    How about "Don't learn to climb on cliffs!!!!". Go to an indoor climbing facility, they'll have many experts, and proper safety equipment to ensure you are not severely injured. Your cliff climbing could go wrong in a number of ways -- even for experts! – SnakeDoc Apr 6 '16 at 22:05
12

From my experience, the simple act of asking won't be perceived as impolite.

There is a good chance that people will let you join them, but be prepared to accept "no" as an answer just in case. It would be impolite to press on and try to get them to change their minds, but if you politely accept the "no", you should be fine. (I assume that you actually want to join the group and belay them, too. If you just ask for a belay and don't offer anything in return, that might probably be seen as rude.)

But this highly depends on the people and on the circumstances; for example, on routes that are well equipped with bolts, I would be more willing to accept new partners than on challenging multi-pitch trad climbs. The same goes for the perceived experience of the potential partner: People that seen experienced and want to try a hard route that I'm also interested in will more likely get a positive response than obviously inexperienced people that beg me to put up a top rope on a UIAA 5 for them.

Of course, this also applies the other way: Make sure that you are comfortable with the people in the group belaying you. See Vetting belayers at the gym?; most things also apply outdoors.

In short: Asking won't hurt, and trying to make sure that you would fit into the group will maximize your chances of joining them.

10

Where I climb (New Mexico, USA), I think it would be impolite to walk up to a stranger outside and ask them out of the blue to belay you. I have been awkward position of being asked to belay someone I don't know / don't want to, and it is certainly uncomfortable.

However, it's certainly not impolite to go to a cliff looking to find new climbing partners or join a group of climbers. Approach them, start a friendly conversation, and explain that you're looking for climbing partners but having trouble finding them, or whatever the case is. You might say you enjoy the area and like to come out even when you don't have someone to go with. This gives them the opportunity to offer to belay you without putting them in the awkward position of having to refuse.

Also, you might offer to belay before requesting a belay. Find an odd-numbered group that seems to be about at your skill level and offer to belay whoever is waiting around. They may be very happy for that and then they'll belay you after that, and you may have made a new friend.

8

I think even asking sometimes can be impolite. Some people just have a hard time saying 'no', even if they don't want you there. If there's a good chance they wouldn't want you in the group, don't put them in a difficult situation.

Probably Don't Ask:

  • A group of 2 climbers obviously on a climbing date
  • An even-number group of climbers who look experienced and setup quickly. They don't need a third/odd person to slow them down
  • Any group of climbers that are having a great time catching up, haven't seen each other in awhile, or sharing inside jokes. You'd be disrupting the social experience for them as they try to accommodate you.
  • If you are inexperienced enough, such that you would need them to coach you through different tasks.
  • If you are missing equipment that you would need to borrow from them.
  • If you sense a great skill imbalance (you are much less experienced than they are), you probably aren't welcome. If you are much more experienced, you might be welcome if they need a lot of help. But you could also be unwelcome if your presence makes them feel intimidated or feel rushed.
  • If you wouldn't feel safe on their anchors or being belayed by them.

Okay To Ask (assuming situation doesn't fall into previous list):

  • An odd-number group of climbers that seem impatient about waiting around. They would probably benefit from your belaying presence.
  • A group of climbers that are around your same skill level (so you guys can climb the same routes)
  • You have a necessary piece of equipment that they are missing, so no one can climb unless you all do it together.
1

For all the reasons in the other answers, one probably should not ask to be belayed by another group of climbers. There's just a lot of awkwardness involved, and a lot of strange risk in trusting someone with your life.

However, if you do want to try to get belayed by others, don't be afraid to use a social approach. Go up to groups and chat with them a bit, show your interest both in the climb and in them. There's a reasonable chance they will offer to let you join, if you play it right. And if they don't, you still spent your time networking with the climbing community. Who knows what you might learn!

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.