7

Every time I have slept in a snow cave, I have woken up to a ceiling that was noticeably lower than when I went to sleep. Is there a good rule of thumb for estimating how much lower it will get?

Apparently, its not just me that has noticed this phenomenon. There are stories from boy scouts who estimate the shrink at 10 inches, skiers in Alaska, people in Antartica, people in California, and climbers on the Grand Teton.

5

If you build it properly this shouldn't happen. If my ceiling sagged overnight I'd assess what I might have done wrong while constructing it, or what I could have done better. Did the pile set properly before I started to hollow it out? Dig I dig the walls too thin? Did I not shape the arch of my ceiling propely?

Instead of figuring out how to predict how much sag you're going to have, you should learn how to build a snow shelter without any resulting sag whatsoever.

Selection of snow is your first and most important task. The absolute best snow to build a shelter in is a wind drift that was laid down in a single storm. The crystalline structure of the snow in wind drifts is already broken, and won't settle much if at all when you cut into it and build your shelter. Wind drifts are also a good indicator of where you should build your shelter, because they only form where there's a break in the wind.

Building a cave in fresh snow or at the top of a loose snow pack is not the best thing to do structurally, because the snow is not settled and is full of air. It's best to first pack the snow down with your snow shoes and let the snow set a bit before you start digging into it. Fluffy snow is great for insulation, but not for structure. The best shelter is one that is built just before a snow, a blanket of fresh fallen snow on top of a solid quinzhee is the type of shelter you could live in for the winter.

In an emergency situation you may be forced to forgo proper site selection and dig-in wherever you can. In these situations, where you do not necessarily build your shelter in ideal structural snow, then how much your shelter may shrink will depend on how loose the snow is, so plan on building your shelter a little bigger than necessary if you think you're going to be in it for longer than waiting out a storm, or spending only one night.

  • Would this depend on conditions? The temperature is likely going to have a big effect on this – user2766 Dec 15 '16 at 15:25
  • @Liam unless we're talking about a major overnight melt then I don't think temperature should cause the roof to sag significantly. I've only slept in snow caves a handful of times though so I don't have tremendous experience. I'd think that walking over the top of your snow cave would be a bigger risk than temperature overall. That being said the kind of snow shelter you are at risk of walking over seems distinct from the one Shem talks about in his answer. I'm thinking of a shelter like the one drawn in this answer outdoors.stackexchange.com/a/104/7995 – Erik Dec 15 '16 at 17:57

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.