8

One of the downsides of an alcohol stove is that the alcohol is all but invisible when it burns, and so the danger is that you won't realize its going and burn yourself.

I have heard that adding regular table salt will make the flame light orange, if that is so how much would one need or are there any other common chemicals one could add?

  • Many chemicals burn different colours, science.se would be helpful here possibly as you'd need to balance colour vs chemical reaction with the alcohol. – Aravona Jun 27 '18 at 8:46
  • 1
    Can't say I've ever had an issue with it before. Even in bright sunlight you can see the distortion of light rays like you would from a candle. I normally just hold my hand several inches above and feel the heat (or not). That is easiest when my skinny pot in on the stove and I want to verify if the stove went out. – topshot Jun 27 '18 at 13:25
  • @topshot That's what I have done to, but still think it would be helpful to if you could make the flame visible and kinda cool – Charlie Brumbaugh Jun 27 '18 at 13:26
  • 1
    I suppose if you have kids or someone that's never used alcohol, but I'd just demonstrate to them that you can't see the flame. I prefer to KISS. – topshot Jun 27 '18 at 13:42
  • I don't have any spare alcohol to play with, but metal ions color flames - sodium very good at it. You could try adding a bit of salt to the alcohol (depending on water content some should dissolve) or some alcohol-soluble sodium compound, maybe soap? – robaki Jul 3 '18 at 16:38
4

There are several methods, one is adding water. The thinking is this: the alcohol should be at about 75% alcohol, and denatured alcohol sold in the US already has some water in it, or other compounds depending on its intended use (or of the means by which it is denatured). So, if you're not good at math, add H₂O and experiment. Otherwise, use the actual alcohol content percentage and factor in the amount of water to use.

Other remedies including using red Heet, which is something I do not advocate, because it burns sooty, and results in toxic gases. Toluene or acetone (nail polish remover) can be used, as that is what we added in chem class with the alcohol burners. However, we weren't cooking food with it, and also, we had vents to remove the poisonous gases given off. And who wants to carry a bottle of toluene on a camping trip anyway?

This came up once as we were considering a scout trip using the stoves. But they are not allowed to be used per BSA policy. The reason - there are two, and the water addresses only one of them - is that the blue flames are extremely difficult to see. This is addressed by the addition of water or other flammable substances. However, alcohol stoves are generally easily tipped over, and nothing can prevent this. In the end, we scrapped the idea altogether - but not before a bit of experimentation.

A word of caution: anything other than a clear blue flame means incomplete combustion. This will cause soot to accumulate on the pot/pan. Be prepared for a bit of cleaning, or apply liquid soap on the bottom.

| improve this answer | |
2

See "How to Make Colored Fire (Ask an Expert)", while the article is intended for fireplaces and not cooking amongst the recommendations is borax which is not very poisonous (in some countries it is used in food, while in others it is banned - so don't drink it or spill it on your food). This will produce a yellowish green flame.

If edibility is extremely important and a waste of good alcohol your least concern consider adding a bit of Sambucca or Vodka. Both add a blue flame.

Also suggested is adding a tiny quantity of white gas, but test your mixture before unleashing it on the Scouts.

On another point: adding green food coloring makes it easier to measure and helps ensure that no one confuses a bottle of it for water. It does not affect the color of the flame.

| improve this answer | |
2

You can try a non chemical way to add visibility to an almost invisible flame: a small metal net layer on top of the flame that the flame will go through and after just a few seconds will be incandescent and glow red / orange

retina rompi fiamma

there are already made devices, I cant find a proper translation, in Italian they are called “retina rompifiamma” or “spargi fiamma” literally flame breaker, their intended use is to evenly distribute heat to the cooking pan above but will glow and maybe sort out your problem

this is a product page i found: https://goo.gl/images/deasRd

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.