After reading this question about emergency kits, I noticed that no one mentioned nails. Why shouldn't we include 10 or 12, common 6d (2", 6 penny) nails in the kit? Ten 6d nails weigh about an ounce (28g) and could be useful in many situations.
I think there are simply not that many uses for nails in emergency situations.
Using nails as intended:
- If you want to build shelter or other wooden constructions you would need a lot of nails - which are heavy.
- Hammering in nails with a rock is rather annoying - and you're not planning to bring a 500g hammer, are you?
- In any case, for shelter and tool use you can just as well rely on cordage (which should be in your emergency kit) - it is arguably more flexible in its use and can serve many different purposes.
- Nails are not easily re-usable, while cordage is. This is relevant, as re-usable means that you need to bring less of the thing which means a smaller and lighter survival kit.
Using nails in improvised ways:
- Yes, there are probably a hand full of uses for nails other than for nailing things down. Maybe improvise a fish hook or something... But frankly, nothing comes to mind that would be really useful and which cannot be done in a different, easier way with the other things your standard survival kit will already contain (such as cordage, tape, wire, ...).
- To work nails into shape you'd likely need pliers - and you probably don't want to carry those just for this, as they are heavy and don't serve too many purposes.
- Nails are primarily to nail things down, it's what they are good at. The kit you bring with you is not made from wood generally, and nailing mostly isn't really part of its construction or fixing any part of it. And while some of the resources you can likely rely on in a survival situation involve wood, nailing wood pieces together is simply not something that is needed too often.
So the answer really is: people don't put nails into survival kits because they don't solve any problem that can't be solved by other, easier/better/quicker/more flexible ways.
So what are better alternatives to nails?
- For fastening: use cordage or create wooden fasteners/dowels using your knife.
- For fish hooks: bring some actual fish hooks, they weigh essentially nothing.
Nails will be extremely useful at a Bug Out Location (BOL), not so much in the Bug Out Bag (BOB) or even the Bug Out Vehicle (BOV). That is why I keep an extensive cache at the BOL, which includes woodworking tools and a large assortment of stainless steel nails. Most of what I cache in terms of woodworking/construction were extras and duplicates of other tools, so there was minimal investment. Example - everyone likely has 2 claw hammers, but probably always go for the same favorite. Those ignored tools went to the BOL cache - not my favorite or even best, but perfectly functional. As far as not making it to my BOL, I have 2 other BOLs which are stocked and occupied by other parties, making my cache abandonable if need be....
For OP, I agree with you that they have great value, but also agree with the others that I would rather reserve that weight in my BOB for more versatile items. However I DO carry 24 small cheap cup hooks in my BOB. They are great for REALLY quick tarp shelters and weigh next to nothing....
If I was considering nails for my survival kit, I think I would probably upgrade to a hand drill instead.
Metal nails are use once and gone, a drill and a knife will make an unlimited supply of holes and wood fasteners.
Keep in mind survival is either short term stationary or it is mobile. Anything you have to leave at the last campsite, does not provide lasting value. Buildings that require nails (or wood pegs) fall in to the same scenarios as planting crops.
Nails are finished metal in a portable form factor. You are not going to randomly find ore and smelt it down to useful steel. By cold forging (pounding the nail as best you can) into a flatter form you can make a makeshift knife or other edged tool (chisel, gouge, reamer/awl). In time a needle or fishhook is possible especially with using a multitool.
As a nail, No. But as material to worked, nails are pretty handy.