5

I just bought a kitchen sink from STS (it is "just" a bag) which says to use it at least 100 meters from water. Since one can use the sink to do anything the distance seems valid, but I wonder -- if one has only a shirt with dirt/sweat to wash, and the soap is biodegradable (Dr.Bronner's) is it still 100 meters or the safe distance is smaller in such case?

  • 1
    Do you mean a camp kitchen sink? Otherwise won’t it be plumbed in? – Darren Aug 7 at 16:28
  • @Darren, ah, sorry :-) This is foldable "bag" which is designed in such way it stands when filled. I used the name STS uses for it (looks like unfortunate choice). For the record, the link: seatosummit.com/product/kitchen-sink – greenoldman Aug 7 at 17:15
  • I see. I was going to direct you to diy.stackexchange.com. 😁 – Darren Aug 7 at 20:37
  • So, basically, a small free-standing soft-side swimming pool for small children or pets. :-) – Bob Jarvis - Reinstate Monica Aug 8 at 17:03
5

It is the soap that is the problem, not the the dirt washed out.

This site Even Biodegradable Soap Can Pollute Water Sources says

We really need to clear up some misconceptions about biodegradable soap. There are many people out there with good intentions who are using biodegradable camp soap or shampoo when camping or backpacking thinking that it is good for the environment. Biodegradable soaps are preferred over other soaps but should still be used at least 200 feet from any water sources.

and on to this (my bolding)

  • Biodegradable soap is NOT biodegradable when it ends up in a river or lake because it requires soil for it to breakdown properly.

  • Biodegradable soap is NOT NATURAL.... it is a chemical.

  • If you wouldn't want to drink it then keep it out of water sources.

The site has other advice about alternatives to so-called safe soap.


Edit:

The website of 99Boulders talks about biodegradable soaps:

Do not dispose of any soapy water in backcountry water sources — even water with biodegradable soap.

Instead, to dispose of soapy water, most biodegradable soap brands and Leave No Trace principles recommend you pour it into a cathole that is 6 to 8 inches deep and 200 feet away from water sources.

Doing so has a couple benefits:

  • It lessens the attraction of wildlife as compared to the “broadcast method” which also broadcasts the smell.

  • It allows bacteria in the soil to biodegrade the soap.


Exploring what it means for something to be biodegradable, the Balance Small Business website about environmentally sustainable businesses, says:

If something is biodegradable, then, given the right conditions and presence of microorganisms, fungi, or bacteria, it will eventually break down to its basic components and blend back in with the earth.

So being biodegradable, does not mean the product is harmless, or can be disposed of anywhere. It means that, in time, in the right conditions, the substance will decay in a way that is not harmful.

| improve this answer | |
  • I don't really see the relevance of your comment "Biodegradable soap is NOT NATURAL.... it is a chemical.". Neither the author nor your quote mention anything about the soap being "natural" or "chemical", furthermore, "natural" means absolutely nothing, unless you're talking about directly taking leaves from a plant and using those as soap. I do agree with the rest of your statement though, you should just treat this soap as any regular soap, except you can, for the most part, throw it away safely. – cliesens Aug 8 at 13:44
  • @cliesens I included that because it was part of the set of 3 bullet points, no other reason. OP asked if the soap is safe if it has only done some mild cleaning and I agree that whether the soap is natural or manufactured isn't relevant to that point, though it might matter to those who choose to use it. The site also lists alternative ways of cleaning, but that is off-topic (although another answer addressing that does seem to be considered on-topic). – Weather Vane Aug 8 at 13:50
  • Because of the comments of the soap itself, I have Dr. Bronner's soap in mind specifically. – greenoldman Aug 9 at 5:14
  • 1
    @greenoldman I added some more to the answer. There is a lot of mention around that Dr Bonner's soap is quite concentrated. – Weather Vane Aug 9 at 6:29
  • @Weather Vane On topic because zero soap is merely a special case of the amount of soap you can use (just like a circle is merely a special case of an ellipse.) :) – ab2 Aug 15 at 21:01
4

First, I agree with @Weather Vane that "it is the soap that is the problem not the dirt washed out." Carrying that further, unless you are going directly to a formal or business function from the trailhead (unlikely!!) you can get a shirt clean enough so that it feels crisp and smells clean and looks pretty good without using soap at all.

This works best if you are near a small waterfall. Just dip the shirt in the bubbly, highly oxygenated part of the stream and rub the dirtiest parts. After a short time, the shirt will be clean enough to feel clean. Sorry, I have never measured the time, because I get mesmerized by the flowing stream. 10 min should be more than enough.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.