20

My Polish grandfather in early 1950's was sent by communist regime to a gulag. People were starving there and malnourishment was common, so they came up with idea of burning some kind of trees and eating the ashes.

Do you know what kind of tree can be devoured like this? And why ashes? How does this method work?

I'm asking here, because it is strictly a survival thing.

  • 9
    In Haiti children eat cookies literally made out of dirt, they don't get any nutrition out of it, they maybe get some vitamins and minerals, but it fills their tummies. Ash is pretty neutral, I don't think it would have given them any nutrition, but it probably helped take the edge off of hunger pains. It could have helped them in other ways too. Charcoal is used in hospitals to absorb ingested poisons, could be the ash helped them keep down other things they were eating. Interesting question though. – ShemSeger May 1 '15 at 19:26
  • 10
    Ash is usually alkaline, so would neutralize a little stomache acid. Not sure how that might be relevant though. – Olin Lathrop May 3 '15 at 14:16
  • @ShemSeger While way past your comment date, may I note that Haitians eating mud/dirt cookies out of hunger is basically a myth, seemingly spun up as clickbait by the media. The World Food Program states "when journalists report about hunger there, they sometimes make reference to people eating cakes made out of mud. Known locally as "galette" these cakes are made out of a special kind of mud that's rich with minerals. People don't usually eat them out of desperation, but as a kind of traditional medicine" on this page wfp.org/videos/famine-food-legends-haitian-mud-cakes – Yogesch Jan 1 at 11:57
  • @Yogesch I used to teach Haitian immigrants, they are the ones who told me about the mud cookies. You'll understand if I take their word over a stranger on the internet. – ShemSeger Jan 2 at 4:53
  • 2
    That may well be the case, but the World Food Program is not a stranger on the internet. And even immigrants are not immune to exaggerating or miscommunicating. – Yogesch Jan 2 at 10:16
15

This is not a survival technique.

The way to determine how many calories is in a particular food item is to measure the amount of heat energy emitted when an item is burned. Anything burned to ash is basically calorie free as far as food value goes.

Ash is composed of whatever was unable to vaporize into smoke in a fire. The hotter the fire, the more material burns. Wood ash has a lot of calcium carbonate and potash (potassium salts) (~35-55%). Traces of metals in the wood will be concentrated in the ash, because it takes a very hot fire to vaporize them. Wood ash can be used to fertilize plants, but not people. It probably wouldn't poison you, and you might get a few trace elements (or some heavy metal poisoning, if the ashes were concentrating some of that).

This is the sort of desperate measure you can try when you are starving to death, and are willing to try anything, even stuff that rationally, you know won't help. I'd expect it to stave off starvation about as well as eating dirt: there might be some questionable, miniscule benefit, but don't plan on it as a technique to live longer.

  • And what do you think about comments to my post? They seem rational about neutralizing other eaten stuff and relieving pain. Is comment about alcalizing stomach acid meaningful? Do I want to alcalize my stomach when starving? – user46147 May 5 '15 at 15:10
  • I've got no idea if making your stomach more alkaline would hurt or not. For that level of detail, ask someone with a medical background. As for the use of charcoal to neutralize poisons, I'd suggest asking another question. The short version is that active charcoal works by preventing the body from absorbing substances, so not good to prevent starvation. Again, someone with a medical background would be better able to answer. – Karen May 5 '15 at 15:41
  • 1
    Apparently dirt isn't calorie free. Hurray internet! – Pepi May 7 '15 at 9:10
  • I think there is a difference between the calorific value of something and how much of that is usable by the human body @Pepi ...I think! – user2766 May 7 '15 at 15:45
  • Furthermore, ash and coal help fighting diarrhea and certain forms of poisoning. Aside of that, the minerals are concentrated. While I wholeheartedly agree that survival is first and foremost a calory game, calories aren't the only thing one needs. – Markus W Mahlberg May 7 '15 at 20:58

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.