4

Okay, besides the emotional preferences, like "in close touch with nature", fun or personal preferences (and so on), is there any rational reason to pick a bow over rifle?

I mean things like "it's quieter and that's good for xy" for example.

  • 1
    Emotional preferences account for about 99% of our preferences for stuff like this, you know. – whatsisname Nov 25 '15 at 4:21
  • 2
    It's quieter and that's good for avoiding the park rangers while hunting where you are not allowed to :) – Philipp Nov 25 '15 at 9:58
  • 3
    It's probably connected to the rational reason for picking hunting over buying your meat it a supermarket. – Michael Borgwardt Nov 25 '15 at 12:35
  • 1
    @MichaelBorgwardt There is no rational reason to do so... – OddDeer Nov 25 '15 at 12:47
5

Other than the stated back to nature (if you can count it as that as most hunters use compounds) it is generally considered both quiter and cheaper.

It is a lot cheaper to buy a bow and arrows than a silenced rifle. Especially as, if you are lucky, you can reuse arrows.

It is down to preference however, as to what a person wishes to use.

  • Why a silences rifle? – Escoce Nov 24 '15 at 23:24
  • It does indeed depend on what you are hunting. If you are after large game which is generally the case with hunting with a bow, well rifles are loud. It can save you a lot of time and effort. It was more to point out a direct comparison. Bows are near enough silent. To buy equivalent equipment it is more expensive. – Dynadin Nov 25 '15 at 5:53
  • More like impossible, even with suppressors firearms are still quite loud. – whatsisname Nov 25 '15 at 7:19
  • 2
    It might be a location thing but a decent compound setup will cost about £1000 here, whereas you are looking at probably around £2000 for a rifle setup. – Dynadin Nov 25 '15 at 11:51
  • 2
    @Mark: only in hollywood. Just the action of many weapons is noisy, which a silencer can do nothing about. – whatsisname Nov 26 '15 at 1:53
5

I find bows are more challenging. Plus, in Ohio for whitetail deer, the archery season last from end the of September through February. The gun season lasts only a week and then an extra weekend. So comparatively, there is a lot more time you can spend in the woods if you're an archer.

For the pricing bit of archery vs guns. Well, my bow (Matthews Z2) cost me 2x what my shotgun (Remington 870 express) cost. Of course, my buddy just bought a turkey shotgun that dwarfs my box cost so that part is all a matter of preference. Arrows themselves are probably about 2-3x the cost of each sabot shotgun slug. Then you need to tack on another $10-20 for broadheads for your arrows. Now yes, arrows can be reused where slugs cannot. Accessories are probably similarly priced for each item when all accounted.

I personally think it is all a matter of preference and how long your seasons last. Plus, it is fair easier (and cheaper) to do more target shooting with a bow than it is with a gun. Even if you're reloading rifle ammo, you're still gonna surpass the cost of arrows rather quickly. People may be recoil sensitive so they may go archery instead. Others may be felons and not able to buy a gun. We have background checks for guns, but you can pick a bow off the shelve here. As for the noise part of it, should you really be looking to fire multiple shots? Guns make it easier for multiple since they're quicker (mostly), but I don't think you should go into it with the notion that you'll want to fire multiple shots.

  • I know in places like California you can hunt for deer with a bow earlier than you can hunt with a rifle, and use a bow during rifle season. This means you can hunt earlier, and longer if you don't fill your tags. – Erik Nov 17 '16 at 16:45
  • Plus, the availability of different game you can hunt with one weapon goes up with a bow. Don't wanna shoot a squirrel with a 12ga. Also, AFAIK in Ohio, you can carry different broadheads for different game while hunting where you can't combine shot/slug combos with your gun. It just opens things up more really. – Branco Nov 17 '16 at 16:54
  • That's something I never considered. I've only been hunting on the west coast so I always think rifles for big game, never shotguns. – Erik Nov 17 '16 at 17:02
  • Ohio recently legalized straight-walled cartridge rifles for whitetail deer. Prior to that it was only shotguns, bows, and long barrel handguns. My buddy has a 30-06, and I am fairly sure he can't shoot anything but paper here with it. – Branco Nov 17 '16 at 17:08
4

You didn't mention your intended use - so lets go with it;

Hunting; - longer season - potential access to different game - when you shoot it, you don't scare off every animal within ear shot - if you manage to kill something, you are one bad mother

Targeting; - cheaper to re-use arrows - you can shoot most anywhere (park, back yard, etc) - if you manage to hit something, you are one bad mother

Survival; - you can repair a bow with elements from the wild - you can make your own arrows - living off only a bow makes you one bad mother

General; - uncle Sam seems to think its OK to run around with a deadly bow in your hand vs. a not so deadly 22. - owning a bow makes you one bad mother.

Cheers

-3

Rational reasons:

You get to go in there BEFORE the Rifle season begins so they are less pressured!

Your shot opportunities at your spots are close distance anyway.

With bow you will usually be able to take at least two shots before they bolt, since it's so much quieter.

Getting a bow kill (from the ground) gives you way more bragging rights.

NOTE: when you miss, it often can happen that you'll lose the arrows as they dive under the soft earth and oak leaves. A good carbon fiber arrow and broadhead is EXPENSIVE! For me they are like around $17 bucks a pop! So be sure you take that into consideration in your planning.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.